Skip to main content
Call Now — (973) 840-7000
DWI Topics

Alcotest 9510 in New Jersey: What the Lifted DWI Stay Means for Your Case

New Jersey's Supreme Court ended the statewide hold on Alcotest 9510 DWI cases on December 19, 2025, but it never ruled that the machine is reliable. If your Essex County DWI involves a 9510 breath test, whether it sat on hold for two years or is brand new, here's what the order says, what it leaves open, and what to check before your court date.

Disclaimer: This page summarizes New Jersey Supreme Court orders and opinions and NJ statutes for education only. It is not legal advice and does not predict court or MVC outcomes. Confirm your situation with a licensed New Jersey attorney.
A person blowing into a handheld portable breath tester showing a .000 reading
A handheld portable breath tester. This is not an Alcotest 9510, the station-based instrument New Jersey uses for evidential breath tests. Photo: U.S. Air Force / Senior Airman Natasha Stannard (public domain, via Wikimedia Commons).

The Short Answer

From May 1, 2023 until December 19, 2025, many New Jersey DWI cases that depended on a breath reading from the Alcotest 9510 were frozen by a New Jersey Supreme Court order while a judge examined whether the new machine is scientifically reliable. That review never finished. The defendant in the lead case, State v. Cunningham, withdrew her challenge, and on December 19, 2025 the Court dismissed the matter and lifted the stay "so that prosecutions may proceed, including prosecutions that rely on the Alcotest 9510."

Two things follow from that order, and both matter if you have a pending case in an Essex County municipal court. First, cases that were on hold are moving again, so a DWI from 2023, 2024 or 2025 can come back onto the calendar with little warning. Second, the Court did not rule that the 9510 is reliable. Its order says that "[d]efendants in individual cases may of course challenge the scientific reliability of the Alcotest 9510 if they so choose." The question was left open, not answered.

This page walks through what the stay was, why it ended, what the order does and doesn't decide, and the practical questions people with older or newer 9510 cases are asking now. It is general information about court orders and statutes, not legal advice about your case.

Why New Jersey Replaced the Alcotest 7110

New Jersey has used Dräger-made Alcotest instruments for evidential breath testing since 2000. The model the State relied on for most of that time was the Alcotest 7110 MKIII-C. In State v. Chun, 194 N.J. 54 (2008), the Supreme Court found results from that model, operated under the protocols it set out, reliable enough to be admitted in DWI cases, and it required the machines to be recalibrated twice a year.

According to the Court's 2023 order, the State told the Court it was switching to the Alcotest 9510 because the manufacturer had discontinued the 7110 and certain replacement parts needed to keep it running were no longer available. The problem was legal as much as technical: Chun's approval was built on a record about the 7110. Nobody had built a comparable record for the 9510, and defendants in municipal courts had begun challenging its results.

That matters because breath results carry so much weight under N.J.S.A. 39:4-50. A reading of 0.08% or higher is enough on its own to prove the "per se" version of DWI, and the reading also drives the penalty tier for a first offense. If the reading is excluded, the State has to prove impairment another way, usually through the officer's observations and field sobriety tests, or the case may not be provable at all. Our main page on how the Alcotest works and how a reading can be challenged covers the instrument itself.

What the 2023 Stay Did

In early 2023 the State asked the Supreme Court to take up the reliability question directly so it could be resolved once for the whole state instead of town by town. On May 1, 2023 the Court certified one case, Colleen Cunningham's, appointed Appellate Division Judge Richard J. Geiger to develop a record, hear expert testimony and make findings on the scientific reliability of the Alcotest 9510, and ordered the proceedings to run on an accelerated basis.

The same order imposed what the Court called a limited stay of DWI matters involving the 9510 in municipal courts and in appeals. Prosecutions that depended on 9510 results were put on hold. The order allowed cases to move forward where the State chose to proceed without the 9510 reading and rely instead on clinical evidence, including objective observational evidence. In practice that meant some 9510-era cases were tried on observations alone, while others, especially those built mainly on a breath number, sat and waited.

The stay did not affect cases that used the older 7110, blood-test cases, or cases where the State never sought to use a 9510 result.

Why the Review Never Reached a Decision

The Court's December 19, 2025 order lays out the history. Most of the delay came from a fight over who would pay for defense experts and transcripts. Cunningham argued that because the State had asked for a statewide ruling, it should not be up to one defendant to fund a challenge with "broad implications," and she pointed to State v. Cassidy, 235 N.J. 482 (2018), where the Court had made the State pay for an indigent defendant's experts. Judge Geiger initially agreed. The Supreme Court vacated that ruling in October 2023, later declined again to make the State pay for defense experts, and in July 2025 directed the State to pay only for daily transcripts.

Cunningham then moved to withdraw her reliability challenge. With no defendant still contesting the machine, and none of the eight other defendants the State had originally identified asking to be added, the Court found there was "no legal question for this Court to decide." It considered alternatives, such as running the hearing without a named defendant or having the Court fund experts itself, and rejected them as unworkable and likely to cause more delay. It stressed that defendants statewide are entitled to their day in court and that the public is entitled to timely resolution of DWI matters. Then it dismissed the appeal, vacated the May 2023 order, and lifted the stay effective immediately.

Got a new court notice on an older DWI? If your Essex County case was held during the 9510 stay and is now back on the calendar, the first conference is the time to sort out discovery, scheduling and whether the breath reading is worth challenging. A licensed New Jersey DWI attorney can review the notice and your file.

Request a Confidential Consultation

What the December 2025 Order Means, and What It Doesn't

It means stayed cases go forward

Municipal courts can now schedule, try and resolve DWI cases that were held because of the stay, and prosecutors can use 9510 readings as evidence. Courts across the state had a backlog of these matters, so many people received notices in early 2026 about cases they had not heard about in a long time.

It does not mean the 9510 was found reliable

No special master report was filed, no findings were made, and the Supreme Court issued no ruling on the merits. That is different from the 7110, which went through the full Chun process. The Court expressly preserved the right of individual defendants to challenge the 9510's scientific reliability in their own cases.

It does not mean every challenge is practical

The Cunningham history shows why. A general scientific-reliability challenge requires expert testimony, and the Supreme Court twice declined to make the State pay for the defense experts in that case. It left open an application to the Office of the Public Defender for ancillary services for defendants who qualify; Cunningham applied and was found ineligible. For most people, a broad attack on the instrument's science is expensive and uncertain. Narrower, case-specific issues are often where defense review starts.

Case-Specific Issues That Still Apply to Any Breath Test

Whatever happens with the science, every breath result still has to be produced the right way. Rules developed under the 7110 and the Chun order shape what defense attorneys look for, and many of the same questions apply to a 9510 test:

  • Calibration and maintenance records. Cassidy is the clearest example of what can go wrong. The Court held there that Alcotest results from machines calibrated without a thermometer producing NIST-traceable temperature readings were inadmissible. According to the opinion, a State Police coordinator was charged with skipping that step and falsely certifying calibrations for machines in Middlesex, Monmouth, Ocean, Somerset and Union Counties, and the Attorney General identified 20,667 people whose breath samples came from those machines.
  • The observation period. New Jersey requires that the person be observed for 20 minutes before a breath sample to make sure nothing like vomiting or regurgitation contaminates the result.
  • Operator certification. The officer who ran the test needs to have been certified to operate the instrument at the time.
  • Foundational documents. The State must turn over specific records about the instrument and the test. Our guide to DWI discovery in New Jersey explains what is typically requested and what happens if it isn't produced.
  • The stop and the arrest. A breath reading obtained after an unlawful stop or an arrest without probable cause can be suppressed regardless of how accurate the machine is.

None of these points guarantees anything in a particular case. Whether any of them applies depends on the actual records, which is why the file matters more than the headline about the stay.

If Your Case Sat on Hold for Two Years

People whose cases were stayed often ask whether the delay itself is a defense. New Jersey decides speedy-trial claims case by case under the four factors from Barker v. Wingo, as applied to DWI cases in State v. Cahill, 213 N.J. 253 (2013): how long the delay was, why it happened, whether the defendant asserted the right, and what prejudice resulted. A statewide stay ordered by the Supreme Court to resolve a scientific question is a very different reason for delay than a prosecutor who simply isn't ready, and courts weigh the reason heavily. How that plays out depends on the facts, including what has happened since December 19, 2025. Our page on DWI speedy-trial rights in New Jersey explains how those factors work.

A long gap also has practical effects worth raising early with counsel. Witnesses move, officers retire or change departments, and video and records have retention schedules. On the other side, your memory of the night has faded too. Gathering what you have now, including receipts, texts, your timeline and names of anyone who was with you, helps whoever reviews the case.

If You Were Arrested After December 19, 2025

New cases with a 9510 result proceed like any other DWI. There is no stay to wait for. The usual timeline applies: a first appearance in the municipal court for the town where you were stopped, discovery, conferences, and a motion or trial schedule. Essex County has more than a dozen municipal courts, and the Essex County municipal courts guide on this site lists them.

Penalties are unchanged by the stay ending. For a first offense, they depend largely on the reading, and they include a license forfeiture and ignition interlock requirements under N.J.S.A. 39:4-50, along with fines, fees and the Intoxicated Driver Resource Center program. A refusal to give breath samples is a separate violation under N.J.S.A. 39:4-50.4a with its own penalties. See our New Jersey DWI penalties overview for the statutory tiers.

A Checklist for Anyone With a 9510 Breath Test

  1. Find your paperwork. The summonses, any notice from the court, and the breath test result sheet if you were given one. Write down the date of arrest and the municipal court listed.
  2. Check the case status. New Jersey's municipal court case search on njcourts.gov lets you look up a ticket. If you received a new notice, note the date and what type of event it is.
  3. Don't assume the old case went away. A case that went quiet during the stay is not dismissed unless a court dismissed it.
  4. Write down your timeline now, including when you last ate and drank, any medical conditions, and anything unusual about the testing room or the wait before the test.
  5. Talk to a licensed New Jersey DWI attorney before your court date about discovery, calibration records and whether any challenge to the reading makes sense in your case.

Sources

This page summarizes New Jersey Supreme Court orders and opinions and New Jersey statutes as of October 2026 for education only. It is not legal advice and does not predict how any court or the MVC will handle a particular case. Confirm your situation with a licensed New Jersey attorney.

Discuss Your Situation
Confidential · No obligation · Fast response

Thank You

We received your request. Someone will be in touch promptly to discuss your situation.

By submitting, you consent to being contacted about your inquiry. Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. This site is a legal marketing resource.

Related Topics

→ Challenging an Alcotest Reading → DWI Discovery in New Jersey → DWI Speedy Trial Rights → New Jersey DWI Penalties
FAQ

Alcotest 9510 Questions

Is the Alcotest 9510 stay still in effect in New Jersey?
No. On December 19, 2025 the New Jersey Supreme Court dismissed State v. Cunningham, vacated its May 1, 2023 order and lifted the limited stay effective immediately, so DWI prosecutions may proceed, including those that rely on Alcotest 9510 breath results.
Did the NJ Supreme Court rule that the Alcotest 9510 is reliable?
No. The challenge was withdrawn before the special master made findings, so the Court decided nothing on the merits. Its order says defendants in individual cases may still challenge the scientific reliability of the Alcotest 9510 if they choose.
Why was the Alcotest 9510 stay put in place?
The State replaced the Alcotest 7110, which State v. Chun (2008) had found reliable, with the 9510 after the manufacturer discontinued the 7110. Because no court had made reliability findings for the new model, the Supreme Court appointed Judge Richard J. Geiger in May 2023 to hold hearings and stayed DWI matters that depended on 9510 results in the meantime.
My DWI was on hold during the stay. Will it be dismissed now?
Not automatically. Lifting the stay lets held cases move forward. Whether any defense applies, such as a speedy-trial claim under State v. Cahill or a challenge to calibration or foundational documents, depends on the facts and records of your case and should be reviewed with a licensed New Jersey attorney.
Can I still challenge my Alcotest 9510 breath result?
Yes. Beyond a general scientific-reliability challenge, which requires expert testimony, defendants can raise case-specific issues such as calibration records, the 20-minute observation period, operator certification, missing foundational documents, and the legality of the stop and arrest. State v. Cassidy (2018) shows calibration failures can make Alcotest results inadmissible.

DWI case with an Alcotest 9510 breath test?

Essex County DWI defense marketing resource. Confidential consultation requests welcome.